Choosing the right roof for your home can feel overwhelming. With so many factors to consider, from cost and durability to maintenance and how it will handle Ontario’s harsh winters, it’s hard to know which material will truly perform best. But making the wrong choice can lead to costly repairs, ice dam damage, or a roof that doesn’t perform through Ontario’s harsh climate.
For homeowners in Barrie, Newmarket, and surrounding areas, a modern metal roof can offer superior durability, energy efficiency, and long-term value compared to traditional asphalt shingles.
This guide focuses on metal roofing, and how it compares to asphalt shingles, to help you make a confident, informed decision.
Metal roofing has become increasingly popular due to its strength, longevity, and energy efficiency. Modern metal roofs come in a variety of materials, including:
A specific type of metal roof is standing seam metal roofing, where panels interlock at raised seams to prevent moisture infiltration. This style is particularly beneficial in areas with heavy snow, strong winds, or wildfire risk.
Other metal roofing options include metal shingles, tiles, and ribbed panels, which offer more aesthetic versatility but may come at higher costs.
Here are some of the key differences between metal roofing and shingles at a glance:
| Feature | Metal Roofing | Asphalt Shingles |
| Lifespan | 40-50+ years when properly installed and maintained. | Most last 20-40 years though certain product lines offer lifetime warranties up to 50 years. |
| Durability | Strong and resistant to wind, snow, and fire. | High-quality shingles are durable but can be affected by temperature and impact over time. |
| Maintenance | Very low. Occasional inspection is recommended. | Moderate. Periodic inspections and small repairs keep shingles in top condition. |
| Weather Performance | Excellent for shedding snow and resisting ice buildup. Performs well in extreme temperature swings. | Handles rain and wind well though it can be prone to ice dams if underlayments are insufficient |
| Cost | Higher upfront investment, but long-term value from longevity and low maintenance. | More budget-friendly installation that still provides durability. |
| Energy Efficiency & Eco-Friendliness | Reflective surfaces reduce cooling costs, often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable. | Some cool-shingle options reflect heat, some recycled content available, but shorter lifespan increases material use over time. |
| Best For | Homeowners planning to stay long-term who want premium durability and a distinctive look. | Homeowners seeking dependable performance and a traditional appearance at a lower cost. |
This is just a snapshot of how metal roofing and asphalt shingles compare. For more detailed information on the difference between the two, keep reading.
A roof is a long-term investment, so understanding how long it will last and how well it withstands Ontario’s climate is crucial.
Many metal roofs last 40 to 50 years or more. Factors like coating quality, panel type, and installation details drive longevity. Metal roofs are highly resistant to wind, snow, ice, and fire, and they handle the freeze-thaw cycles common in Barrie, Newmarket, and other Ontario communities exceptionally well.
High-quality shingles typically last 20 to 40 years in our region, however, there are shingles that come with lifetime warranties up to 50 years. But this does depend on product line, ventilation, and maintenance. Impact-resistant and algae-resistant shingles can extend this lifespan, but shingles are more prone to damage from heavy ice, wind, or falling debris. Regular maintenance, inspections, and small repairs help shingles reach their full potential.
Metal roofs offer exceptional durability and a much longer lifespan, making them ideal for homeowners planning to stay long-term. Shingles provide solid performance at a lower cost but may require more frequent maintenance and replacement over the years.
How a roof is installed and maintained has a big impact on its performance and lifespan. Different materials have unique installation requirements and maintenance routines, which homeowners should understand before making a decision.
Installing a metal roof requires experienced professionals to ensure panels are securely fastened, seams are weatherproof, and expansion and contraction are properly accommodated. While repairs are infrequent, periodic inspections, especially after storms, help maintain peak performance and prevent minor issues from becoming major problems.
Shingle roofs are easier to repair in localized areas and generally require less specialized installation expertise, though professional installation is still recommended. Proper underlayment, ventilation, and periodic inspections are key to keeping shingles in good condition. Routine maintenance, like small repairs and gutter cleaning, ensures shingles continue to perform well in Ontario’s challenging winter climate.
Metal roofs demand professional installation but minimal upkeep afterward, while shingles are easier to repair but require ongoing inspections and maintenance to perform reliably over time.
Canadian winters can be pretty tough on roofs. Heavy snow, dense ice, and temperature swings can quickly find weak spots in your roofing system. Our team spends winters repairing emergency leaks and helping homeowners prevent weather damage meaning we see how materials hold up in real condition.
In Barrie, Newmarket, and surrounding areas, winters can bring heavy snow, ice accumulation, and sudden temperature swings. Metal roof panels shed snow quickly, which can reduce overall snow load and structural stress. In addition, the smooth surface stops ice from sticking to your home, reducing the risk of ice dams. If you do decide to go with metal, it can expand and contract with temperature swings, so experienced installation is essential to prevent noise and stress on the roof.
Modern architectural shingles are engineered to withstand high winds and cold weather when paired with proper underlayments, ice and water barriers, and ventilation. With correct installation, shingles provide dependable weather protection and are straightforward to repair if a localized section is damaged.
Both metal and asphalt shingle roofs perform well in Ontario winters with quality installation. The choice comes down to appearance, budget, and maintenance priorities.
When it comes to choosing a roof, the upfront cost and ongoing maintenance can feel just as important as weather performance. Different materials have different lifespans, durability, and repair needs, and understanding these factors can help you make a choice that fits your home and budget.
Metal roofs come with a higher upfront investment but require little routine maintenance beyond standard inspections and gutter care. This combined with their longevity and low maintenance can help offset these costs.
The average cost of metal roofing will vary depending on material, style, and installation complexity but you will most likely be looking at costs in the range of $15 to $20 per sq ft.
Shingles have the lower upfront cost, which is why they remain the most popular roof replacement solution for Ontario homes. With proper installation, routine inspections, and occasional repairs, shingles can deliver reliable protection for years. Maintenance for shingles can sometimes be more expensive if repairs are needed. But high-quality shingles, professional installation, periodic inspections and routine gutter cleaning can help reduce repair costs.
The average cost for properly installed shingle roofs is approximately $6 to $8 per sq ft.
Metal roofing offers long-term value and low maintenance, while shingles provide a more affordable upfront option with dependable performance. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize long-term durability or initial cost.
When choosing a roof, energy performance and environmental impact are increasingly important factors for homeowners. Both metal roofs and asphalt shingles have eco-friendly and energy-efficient options, but they differ in how they perform and contribute to sustainability.
Metal roofs are naturally reflective, helping to reduce heat absorption during Ontario’s hot summer months. This can lower cooling costs and improve home comfort. Many metal roofs are also made from recycled materials and are fully recyclable at the end of their lifespan, making them a sustainable choice. Additionally, metal roofing, like shingles, can support solar panel installation, further enhancing energy efficiency and long-term savings.
Modern asphalt shingles can also be energy-efficient, particularly “cool shingles” that reflect some heat. Some options are made from recycled materials as well. However, asphalt generally absorbs more heat than metal, which can increase cooling costs in the summer. While sustainable options exist, shingles typically have a shorter lifespan, meaning replacement occurs more often, which increases material use over time.
Metal roofs generally offer superior energy efficiency and environmental benefits compared to asphalt shingles. Their reflective surfaces, long lifespan, and recyclability make them a smart choice for homeowners looking to reduce energy consumption and environmental impact, while shingles remain a budget-friendly option with some eco-conscious alternatives.
For Ontario homeowners concerned with snow loads, ice damming, and long-term maintenance, metal roofs can be a smart investment. Shingles remain a reliable choice for those seeking a traditional look with lower upfront costs, but they may require more routine maintenance in harsh winters.
Pros of Metal Roofing:
Cons of Metal Roofing:
Asphalt shingles are a solid option for homeowners who want a budget-friendly, traditional look without the higher upfront cost of metal. High-quality shingles with proper installation, underlayments, and regular maintenance can still provide reliable performance in Barrie, Newmarket, and surrounding areas.
Pros of Shingles:
Cons of Shingles:
Metal roofs provide long-term value and peace of mind, while shingles offer affordability and traditional aesthetics.
Regardless of the material, professional installation is essential. Metal roofing involves precise panel placement and handling of thermal expansion. Shingle roofs require proper underlayment, ventilation, and fastening. Poor installation can reduce lifespan, increase maintenance, and void warranties.
If you’re considering a new roof in Barrie, Newmarket, or surrounding areas, review your options carefully. Comparing materials, costs, and expected lifespan will help you make the best choice for your home.
If you’re still unsure about which option to go with, contact our dedicated team at T. Simpson Roofing for a free, no-obligation roof assessment and estimate. Our team will answer your questions, review metal roofing and shingle options, and help you choose a system that gives you peace of mind and protects your home with confidence.
