Choosing new siding is a big decision for any homeowner. And if you live in Ontario, especially in areas like Barrie, Newmarket, or the surrounding region, the stakes feel even higher. Your siding needs to handle heavy snow, summer heat, freeze–thaw cycles, and strong winds off Lake Simcoe.
Many homeowners end up landing on two main options: vinyl siding and aluminum siding.
Both are popular. Both have strengths. But one may be a better fit for your home if you are looking for durability, energy performance, maintenance needs, and how well it holds up to local climate conditions.
Here’s a clear comparison to help you choose the right siding for your Ontario home.
| Feature | Vinyl Siding | Aluminum Siding |
| Durability | Excellent durability – resists impacts and weather | Good durability but dents easily |
| Energy Efficiency | Strong insulator | Conducts heat, which can affect indoor temps |
| Maintenance | Very low maintenance and colour doesn’t fade | Prone to fading and requires repainting |
| Appearance | Wide variety of modern styles | Metallic look makes it less adaptable |
| Cost | Slightly higher upfront but better ROI | Slightly cheaper but higher lifetime upkeep |
Upfront, aluminum is sometimes a touch cheaper. But most Ontario homeowners recover more value with vinyl because:
For homeowners in fast-growing markets like Barrie and Newmarket, where exterior appearance matters for resale, vinyl typically offers a stronger return.
When it comes to the vinyl vs aluminum debate, durability is often the deciding factor. And it’s where vinyl takes a clear lead.
Aluminum, while rust-proof and fire-resistant, is much softer. In Ontario’s storm season, aluminum dents extremely easily, leaving homes looking worn even if the siding still performs functionally. Over time, those dents and dings reduce curb appeal and home value.
Vinyl siding is thicker and impact-resistant, which means hail, wind-thrown branches, and even a stray baseball usually leave no mark.
Energy efficiency matters in the Barrie and Newmarket region with hot summers and long winters.
Vinyl performs better because it’s made from polyvinyl chloride, which naturally insulates. This means it provides a more stable thermal barrier, which can help with indoor comfort and utility costs. Some homeowners even opt for insulated vinyl siding for a greater boost.
Aluminum absorbs heat during the summer months, making it challenging to stay cool and strain your air conditioner. Additionally, since aluminum is prone to damage, any holes or cracks will make your home lose energy efficiency. And, if you don’t notice the damage, it can cause your bills to skyrocket
Both aluminum and vinyl siding have relatively simple, quick installation processes.
In some cases, installing aluminum is faster as the material is lighter. But if you’re installing aluminum siding as a siding replacement for old aluminum, that isn’t always the case. Often, old aluminum conceals mould, moisture damage, crumbling sheathing, and insect infestations, which can complicate replacement.
Vinyl siding, on the other hand, is:
So, when it comes to installation, we would call this one a tie. The key is professional installation to maximize durability and minimize imperfections.
Homeowners love vinyl because maintenance is minimal. The colour is baked in during manufacturing, so it resists fading and never needs repainting. When it comes to maintenance, a good cleaning with a garden hose every once in a while is all that’s needed to keep your home looking fresh.
Aluminum, as we mentioned earlier, is more vulnerable to damage. That means it requires:
These fixes aren’t always easy and can get costly.
When you install siding, you’re giving your home’s style a facelift. It’s good to have options to match your specific tastes.
Aluminum has undoubtedly come a long way appearance-wise, but it still gives your home’s exterior a metallic appearance. And the reality is, a shiny, metal home could keep future buyers away.
Vinyl siding comes in a wide range of styles popular in Ontario neighbourhoods:
You can also mimic wood siding with a shake-style vinyl siding option. It’s the perfect way to give your home a classic, rustic look.
One downside of vinyl is that it comes pre-painted so you are limited to the available colours (though there are tons of options). The material has a hard time absorbing paint, so it can be challenging to paint over existing siding. That being said, that initial colour never fades, while aluminum requires painting again and again.
Wood siding may look beautiful, but it’s rarely practical in Ontario. It requires heavy maintenance, offers almost no fire resistance, and is highly vulnerable to pests and moisture.
Vinyl is a far more durable, budget-friendly alternative that still allows for a classic wood-look aesthetic.
Vinyl siding is the best choice for homeowners across Barrie, Newmarket, and Simcoe County who want durable, low-maintenance, and energy-efficient siding. It stays looking new longer, withstands local weather conditions, and boosts the value of homes in Barrie, Newmarket, and surrounding areas.
Whichever siding you choose, make sure it’s installed by experienced professionals so your home stays protected for years to come.
If you’re considering replacing your siding in Barrie, Newmarket, or anywhere in Simcoe County, book a free estimate today. Vinyl siding offers the durability, energy efficiency, and long-lasting curb appeal that Ontario homes need. With its wide range of styles and colours, it’s an upgrade that not only protects your home but also boosts its value for years to come.
By choosing vinyl, you’re investing in a siding solution built to withstand Ontario’s weather, reduce maintenance, and keep your home looking its best in every season. Whether you’re updating an older home or enhancing a new build, professional installation ensures your siding performs flawlessly and adds lasting beauty to your property.
